After Felix and Lake break things off, Pilar becomes a close friend to Felix when his mom is put on a psychiatric hold. Pilar soon realizes that she sees him as a sexy Muppet and even musters the courage to kiss him!

Felix doesn't even realize the depth of his feelings for her until he finds that Pilar has stashed Swedish Fish into his suit pocket at the Brooks wedding — Swedish Fish just so happens to be his mom's favorite candy, but it's banned from her facility. And boom! We've got them kissing to "Time After Time" in the very last episode of Season 2